The room is smaller than I thought it would be.
Grey carpet. Grey walls. A table bolted to the floor, as if someone once tried to take it with them.
Senior Sergeant Graham White sits across from me with a paper cup of coffee he hasn't touched. I know Graham. Most people in Castlemaine know Graham. He sits four rows from the back at St Thomas', on the left, next to his wife, and he sings the hymns half a beat behind everyone else.
He hasn't looked me in the eye since they brought me in.
The window on the far wall isn't a window. It's a mirror, and I know what that means. I've watched enough television. I stopped looking at it after the first few minutes. All it showed me was a man in a borrowed tracksuit with his hands in his lap.
Graham reaches out and presses a button on the black box between us. A small red light comes on.
"Interview commencing, four fifty-two a.m." He reads out the date. My full name. His. Then he folds his hands on the table, the way he does at the end of the Lord's Prayer.
"In your own time, Elliot."
I look at the red light for a long moment.
This wasn't the first time I had asked God why He was punishing me.
But this was the first time He answered.
Friday nights smelled like instant coffee and Lynx Africa.
The St Thomas' hall was built in 1868 for something grander than us. Bluestone walls. Tall windows. Radiators that knocked like someone wanting to be let in. But every Friday from seven until nine it belonged to Cornerstone Youth, and to the twenty-odd kids who had nowhere better to be.
A ping pong table with a dip in the middle.
Three couches donated by three different widows, none of them matching.
A tea urn older than me.
And me.
Nine years I'd run Friday nights. Nine years of setting out chairs and stacking them away again. Nine years of driving kids home when no one came to pick them up, and sitting in the car out the front until the porch light came on.
I never minded.
That's what people don't understand about me. I never once minded.
That night Josh and Tayla were fighting over the ping pong table again, because Josh had been "holding it for Lachie" for forty-five minutes and Lachie had gone home at seven thirty. Two of the year nines were filming each other doing something on the couches that was either a dance or a medical emergency. The Henderson twins were eating the Tim Tams I'd hidden in the kitchen, the ones I'd specifically told them were for after the talk.
And Abigail was in her usual spot on the end of the green couch, sleeves pulled down over her hands, watching me the way she always watched me.
Like I was the only adult in the room who had never let her down.
I clapped twice. The hall went on exactly as before.
I clapped three times. Tayla served the ball into Josh's forehead.
"Righto," I said. "Circle. Bring a chair. Henderson twins, bring the Tim Tams, and don't think I can't count."
Tonight was Job.
I'd been saving Job. You can't give a room full of fifteen-year-olds Job too early. They need to have lost something first. A grandparent. A friendship. A parent who said they'd be at the netball final and wasn't.
Every one of those kids had lost something by now.
So I told them about a good man. A man who did everything right. Who prayed and gave and kept his word. And I told them how, one by one, God let it all be taken from him. His animals. His house. His children. His health. Until he was sitting in the ashes, scraping his sores with a broken bit of pot, and his friends were standing over him saying, You must have done something to deserve this.
"Did he?" Josh asked. He had a red mark on his forehead the exact size of a ping pong ball. "Do something?"
"No," I said. "That's the point. He didn't."
"So why'd God do it, then?"
"That's the question, isn't it."
Nobody said anything. The radiator knocked.
Then a small voice from the end of the green couch.
"Did you ever ask Him? Why?"
Abigail. She didn't speak much in circle. When she did, the room went quiet for her.
I could have given her the answer from the study guide. I'd read it. God's ways are not our ways. It's a fine answer. It just isn't one that's ever helped anybody at two in the morning.
So I told her the truth.
"More times than I can count," I said. "I'm still waiting on a reply."
Some of them laughed. Not at me. With me. Josh said, "Same," and Tayla hit him, and the moment let go of the room the way moments do.
But Abigail didn't laugh.
She just nodded. Slowly. As if I had told her something she'd needed to hear for a very long time.
Afterwards I stacked the chairs on my own. I always stacked them on my own. The other volunteer, Judith, has a dicky hip.
I'd had blood taken on the Tuesday. My third lot in two months. Somewhere around the fourth stack of chairs I felt it again: the heaviness behind my eyes, the ache in my joints that came and went like a tide. The doctor at the Castlemaine clinic had done the first two lots. I went to Kyneton for the third, because the doctor in Castlemaine had a way of looking at me over the top of his glasses that I didn't care for.
I didn't mention any of this to the kids. You don't put your own weight on children. That's the first thing they teach you, and the only thing I'd never needed teaching.
When I came out, the car was already in the car park, engine running, headlights on.
A little white Corolla with a dent in the back door.
I'd know the sound of that engine anywhere.
My phone buzzed in my pocket before I'd even reached the passenger side.
Rebecca: Proud of you tonight x
She'd been standing at the back of the hall for the last ten minutes. I hadn't seen her come in. She had a way of doing that. Of being there before you knew you needed her.
"You heard all that?" I said, getting in.
"I heard enough." She reached over and squeezed my knee. "Still waiting on a reply, hey?"
"Something like that."
"He'll get back to you." She smiled. "You're on His good list."
Everyone else called her Becky. Her family. Her friends. The kids at the high school, where she worked three days a week in a little office with a box of tissues and a poster about breathing.
I never had.
Becky was a girl who drank cans in the back of a ute after the footy. Rebecca was a name you said in church.
She was Rebecca to me. From the very first day.
My Rebecca.
Sunday lunch was at Mum's. Sunday lunch was always at Mum's.
Roast lamb with rosemary from the bush by the back door. Potatoes that had been in the oven since we left for the ten o'clock service. Gravy from the packet, because Mum said life was too short, and peas because Mum said a plate needs something green or the Lord will notice.
The same house I grew up in. The same weatherboards, the same lemon tree, the same cross-stitch in the hall that says The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want, with the w in want done in the wrong colour because she ran out of thread in 1994.
The same chair at the end of the table that nobody sat in.
Dad hadn't sat in it for a very long time. That chair was a whole other story, and I didn't tell it on Sundays.
"Any news from the doctor?" Mum asked, before I'd even taken my coat off.
"Waiting on results."
"Still?"
"They're thorough." I sat down. "Which is good. You want them to be thorough."
She put her hand flat on my cheek the way she'd done since I was small. Her hands always smelled like Sunlight soap and hand cream.
"You're not eating," she said.
"I'm eating."
"You look thin."
I wasn't thin. But I didn't argue. I hadn't had an appetite in weeks. Everything tasted like cardboard. I told her that, and she nodded like I'd confirmed something she'd suspected for weeks, and she gave me the crispy potato from the corner of the tray. The one she always saves.
I had seconds of the lamb. Mum's lamb is the exception to most things.
After lunch I dried while she washed. The same tea towel with the map of Tasmania on it. The window over the sink looking out at the lemon tree, and past it the back fence, and past that the hills, gone purple in the afternoon.
"Whatever it is," she said, without looking up from the sink, "you'll get through it. You always do."
"I know."
"You're a good Christian, Elliot." She handed me a plate. "And God loves you. Don't you ever forget that."
I never did.
It was the one thing in my life I never had to doubt.
The clinic rang on Monday at 10:14 in the morning. I was in the car outside the Coles, a shopping list on the passenger seat. Bread. Milk. Panadol.
"Mr Holmes? It's Kira from the clinic. Dr Patel's had a look at your bloods."
My mouth went dry. I remember that. The way my hand found the steering wheel and held it.
"Okay," I said.
"So everything's come back within the normal range." A pause. Paper moving. "Dr Patel would just like you to come in for a follow-up, so he can have a chat about how you're—"
Within the normal range.
I understood what that meant, even if she didn't. Three lots of blood. Two clinics. Two months of feeling like my body belonged to somebody who didn't like me very much. And they'd looked as hard as they knew how, and they'd found nothing.
Inconclusive.
That was the word for it. I've used it ever since.
Because nothing is worse than something. You can fight something. You can name it, and pray against it, and tell people about it so they know how to pray for you.
You can't fight nothing.
You can only carry it.
"Mr Holmes? Did you want to book that follow-up?"
"I'll call back," I said. "I'll check my diary and call back."
I meant to.
I sat in that car park after she hung up, with the engine off. A woman went past with a trolley full of toilet paper and a toddler asleep on top of it. Someone's car alarm went off and stopped. The sky over the Coles was the flat white it goes in May, when the frosts start and the whole town smells like wood smoke by four in the afternoon.
I didn't go in for the bread.
That night I knelt beside my bed.
I don't do it every night. I'm not a performer about my faith. But some nights the knees go down on their own.
The heater ticked. The house was cold in the corners the way old houses are. Through the wall I could hear the neighbour's television, a game show, a studio audience clapping for somebody else's good fortune.
I didn't pray for healing. I'd done that. I'd done that for two months.
I didn't pray for patience. I'd been patient my whole life.
I just asked Him what I always asked Him. The same question, worn smooth from handling, like a stone you keep in your pocket.
Why are You doing this to me?
I waited.
The heater ticked. The audience clapped.
Nothing.
It wasn't the first time I'd heard nothing.
I'd been hearing it my whole life.
In the interview room, Graham's phone buzzes against the table.
He turns it over. Reads it. Something in his jaw sets hard, the way it does when Father Andrew runs over time. He turns the phone face down again and doesn't say who it was.
"Go on, Elliot," he says. "Friday night. The youth group."
"Is she here?" I ask.
He doesn't answer that. He just looks at the red light, then at the mirror, then, for the first time since they brought me in, at me.
"Friday night," he says again.
So I tell him about Friday night.
I tell him everything.
Well.
I tell him what matters.